Showing posts with label Dan Dennett. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dan Dennett. Show all posts

Friday, January 2, 2009

[69] Same Book, Still Going

Ok I'm about half way through this monster of a book and a few themes need to be reiterated. For one moment I'd like to state for the record that beside in anything other than a purely satiric nature, I've never told anyone they were going to go to hell. This I'm finding pretty fucking offensive as the caring and loving nature of Jesus' disciples cuts a little too deep when it comes from people who's heads are well traversed amid the depths of their ass. It doesn't so much bother me the statement in itself as much as the level of pure ignorance from which it comes. It is my opinion that nobody with even half the opportunities you've been given to be able to read this blog, has any excuse to not do actual research before they go and make such glaring statements.. This book is about 500 pages. That's 500 more pages I will be in front of my friends who subsequently still tell me to look around in wonder as "proof" for god's existence. I'm bringing an army to a boxing match and the boxer is using a pillow.

Well, onto the themes. One which I personally find the most fun is the utter ridiculousness of rationalizing a god with all the typical powers. You know, omniscience, omnipotence, benevolence, omni-whatever else. If it was simple enough for people to  ridicule with such precision and tell-allness without modern day science, you'd think that would speak volumes to people who rely so heavily on those "arguments" that stem from vague memories asserted from authority, and not personal reasoning. The great thing that apologetics have learned to do when trying to acclimate the faith is to forgo agreeing upon definitions before they begin or take it a step farther and explain why the main issue that would cripple their view doesn't apply in the "context" (aka bullshit personal bias) that their reasoning needs. Countless times you see through history that it was first human progression, second the church who dragged its heals the entire way, then decided to get on board. Slavery, women's rights, witch hunts, animal cruelty, WWII, sooner or later it will be homosexuality and stem cells if we're lucky.  Every modern day should be another nail in the enormous coffin it's going to take to amass all the absurdity and harm this decrepit dogma has bestowed.

Continuing, Carl Sagan tells a lot about the witch hunts and all the people killed, on ZERO evidence, at the prospect of the conspirators to get their assets or money. This reminded me of the debate, in w/e vague sense you can call such a spectacle, between D'Souza  and Dennett. During the question and answer session one of the students asks Dinesh something referring to the atrocities Christianity has purported in the past to which D'Souza gave a telling and ignorant reply. He rants a bit about how Stalin killed thousands "in the name of atheism", which is enough for anyone who knows anything about the definition of atheism or Stalin to write off D'Souza,  then proceeds to say during the whole time the Salem witch trials took place only 11 people were killed. Now the idea that he would even resort to reducing murderous crimes done out of ignorance and injustice, not to mention kinda maybe suggested by the bible, to a simple number battle bothers me, I mean it was only tortured death. The icing on the cake is that he apparently glossed over the fact that witch hunts burned a few more than he would like to believe. By a few I mean several thousands, especially if they belonged to the women and children variety. The worst part of our modern day heroes and pioneers debating under these conditions is that, if your speaking to an audience with attention spans that barely understand crappy movies, of course if they have no knowledge in the subject before hand, they're going to lean with the guy who speaks with passion(desperate yelling) and word play("hey I'm the cool guy" god joke).

Anybody who feels I am beating this subject into the ground is right. I've been sick of feeling like I repeat myself with no adequate rebuttal from the people I actually care to hear from for a really long time now. I take solace in the fact that as far back as one could write about this stuff and not get killed, people have felt the same way but still had the underlying appreciation for their freedom to write it and an overall hope for the one day it will all be over. I'd like for these to be somewhat of a testament to my actual truth that I care about people's liberation of mind and by just sitting back and bitching to myself, I'm no better than the guy who says I'm going to burn in hell for not believe like him. If you do that by the way, fuck you. You're not worthy of much greater a response.

None of these people have seriously tried to embody the "atheist or agnostic" position. None. Not seriously, not "I have been one in the past" either. It's a boldface lie, which I'm learning is not a "sin" most Christians give two shits about disobeying. And I don't mean to even just haphazardly forgo your faith and play pretend, I mean to sit back and let the "I don't knows" really sink in. I mean for you to not say "o look an anti-faith book, commence scary music!" and run away. There is in no way shape or form it is just a mere choice for me to say I don't believe or don't know. It's just the fucking truth. My recourse didn't come from "god did it" so I looked for real proof and wah-lah I wasn't alone. Who thinks it was just easy for me to drop any hold that lifelong embedded superstition had on me? Who cared to ask in a manner that wasn't accusing me of never believing in the first place? Do you think it's a fun position to hold thinking your friends trapped by tradition are forcefully denying themselves the beauty of the real world, the power that mental stimulation and a reasoned outlook can give you? It's like I have the best invented drug ever made with zero negative side effects, but it's just a little too hard to understand and takes a little too much time pick up so let's all just gnaw on our red meat.

I don't think there is much left for humanity to try to finally work out than this quarrel between religion, science, morals, origins, and the self. I don't understand how a belief in a speculative, by definition impossible to realize, place of never ending worship and lobotomies, is enough to trump amazing facts about our world. What sick power does one feel when they can't wait for some of the greatest minds in history to burn in hell because they've shown another reason to get over the myths.  Their mind is unsettled ipso facto someone else is automatically wrong. It's so simply consoling it's just sick.

No single raindrop thinks it's responsible for the flood.


Saturday, December 27, 2008

[67] Those Books Get Me Going

I've gotten about a fourth of the way through "The Portable Atheist" and, go figure, I can all but refrain from banging my head against the wall when I think about what I'm reading in the book contrasted with what I'm hearing from the faithful position. When I said that arguments people use today were used, and thoroughly refuted in the past, it was a grand understatement. People are slaves to themselves, and we can see this when we understand why we are slaves to history. The same recurring patterns in thought don't just magically arise from the One True Basin of stupidity, but they do in fact remain alive when people excuse their ignorance. I've made it a concentrated effort on my part to not just be another non-believer. I cannot say I've been equally respected from the other side. It angers me to think that brilliant people have put sometimes their lives on the line to expose the pure and blatant illogical premises and contradictions in theistic arguments, and yet authors today are still received with the same garbled and recycled bullshit, to put it frankly, as some logical equivalent to be wrestled in a debate arena. 

"An evangelical preacher is not obliged to be well read" George Eliot. This is one of I assure you many lines that stood out for me while reading and its simplicity speaks to why the factuality behind it is so powerful. It is not exactly easy to sit and read a 400 page book on anything, and most people today are masters at finding every excuse in the world as to why they are too busy or too disinclined to find the time to read anything. This is more than just a tragedy, because now instead of simply being able to write off the ill-informed as meaningless and insignificant, we now have a regular wall of ignorance of beleaguered despots who spout their "Divine Word" as if its stemming from this universal desperate position which requires a level of piety only understood by the truly inoculated to the falsehoods of this pitiful word.

I used to say that I was ok if someone believed in something as long as it did not hurt anyone and made them happy. I don't know if I'm entirely comfortable with the position as it is becoming too vast of an issue to account for solid definitions regarding harm, happiness, belief, or god. The one position I still maintain is that people are self centered and be it through a gaping hole or passive one, all of their actions will be traced back to something self fulfilling. This isn't to say that progressive and helpful actions have anything taken away from them, but when you read enough and listen to the brain scientists lecture the real facts about your humanly situation sink in.

Here's an anecdote that will help illuminate why I'm so presently frustrated. I'm reading this book, I have another one lined up, and I've just sat through another few hours of Beyond Belief lectures. My mother, who I've disregarded as such and never treat in a way that would make sense for her to continually talk of thinking and praying for me, sends me A Purpose Driven Life by Rick Warren. This I not only found to be simply pathetic, but overtly offensive. I've spend the time to actually learn and establish a position, her half-assed attempt at reaching out and connecting is to throw a too typical piece of insufferable lacking in coherence book at the duh-fact that I like to read. It really bothered me that when I picked it up to discover it was a book within the wrapping, no other book popped into my mind about what it would be when I opened it. "Christian" is not some stance on life that can assert its truth and authority over your dominion, it's a PATHETIC and TELEGRAPHED set of demonstrable beliefs that work on the people who dwell in bullshit excuses. I'm sick of finding no other word to describe instances like this as anything but typical. I want to burn the book, take pictures, and send them to her with a simple "you've got to be kidding me" note attached. That woman actually believes that her prayers may in one way or another work and manifest into some "miracle" that I guess is supposed to make us civil with each other. And if not, o well it is still will be just some hard to deal with part of her god's plan.

All these people hoping for heaven and talking of this sad and depressing situation they find themselves in. Who are you and why are you looking for trouble? People who are this sad and lonely all the time must be asking for it because the, while pissed off, unbeliever here remains pissed off, I'm never sitting back rubbing my hands together for what may be some day promise from biblical yokels. You have a fucking choice in regards to how you think and act during your life and if you don't realize it soon I'm going to make it a personal vendetta to bring shame and ridicule upon dealers of this faith based drug. I tried to leave it up to people to take self responsibility and evolve, yet that does not appear to work ,so in retort the unapologetic activist can step in.

Another thing, stop levying the charge starting with "Have you read such and such book" because 99 times out of 100 what your trying to say about me has nothing to do with a bigger point I'm trying to make. The very title of Rick Warrens book to me presupposes that those without a belief in god cannot find purpose which is utterly insane and offensive. I've listened to Rick Warren talk about the book and his position, he seems like a nice guy. I've listened to Dan Dennett refute a key gaping logic aspect to the book and I've perused it a bit myself. Forgive me if I'm sick of hearing the same things and played out notions again and excuse my resistance to biblical quotes poised as evidence. Lee Strobel, who's famed "Case for Christ" is frequently suggested to me, has a degree in law, not physics, not theology, not biology, not astronomy, not a plethora of other things that he haphazardly skews together as this magnificent case. Not to mention the 2 part, like 3 hour long absolute tearing apart of the "documentary" he made based from the book. And finally the bible. What's the biggest thing people want to do in defending their faith? Hands down, quote the bible, close second comes some personal experience story. By me playing by their rules, quoting the bible, I can make them look just as stupid as they make themselves, yet unless I read the entire thing and from their opinion,or "faithful understanding" no less, my simple charges of it not being factually, morally, logically, and scientifically correct don't just up and disappear because you've tried to divert the issue and discredit my "interpreting" ability. Then try to get me started on all the people you've never even heard of, let alone read.

I don't think you deserve your truth. It'd be like handing a 12 gauge to a five year old. I still don't think I'm "better" than any of the people that so frequently piss me off, but I do think my information is better, trustworthy, and verifiable. I think my position is supported and can be independently confirmed. My way of thinking provides clarity and truth to people who are ready to find it. And this is not because I'm some ordained prophet who's had some secret revealed to me about the nature of life, nor because I think I can survive death.

For the love of Goodness will you please encourage the faithful to pick up, o I dunno, maybe 1 or 20 of the books written in the last few hundred years that explain why they no longer need to inculcate dogma to be happy. Maybe people will stop feigning like their glorifying god and start to glorify life.

Monday, September 1, 2008

[60] The Gates Of Hell

The Gates of Hell
D'Souza just can't get over himself can he? In a closing remark with his debate with Dan Dennett, D'Souza states that its god respecting your denial of him and allowing you to enter hell. Ummm can no one see where this is slightly skewed reasoning? Aside from this being based from completely subjective Christian logic, when has anyone made a choice to not believe in something and then be punished accordingly by rules which can't be agreed upon? When you made up your mind that Santa didn't exist, did your parents slap you around a bit because keeping the dream will make you behave a little better around the holidays?

Dinesh speaks to those who want a sermon. It can be loud, it can drift from here and there, take in parts of this and that, dosn't actually have to be coherent but by golly he said it with such passion and went to school for this stuff, how could he be wrong? Over and over and over, hell one more over and over he comes to the table with "We have NATURAL LAWS and five senses that restrict our information, restrict our understanding." IN THE NEXT SENTENCE he says, a belief in god (a being outside of nature) is the MOST PLAUSIBLE and, according to Occam's Razor, most likely considered correct for its simplicity. Hold on one second there Dinesh 'ol boy I think you just shot yourself in the head and then thought to yourself, thank god I remembered to load this thing.

I like to keep the arguments for god removed from critism of the bible or a specific religion. As if it wasn't shaky enough ground to try and argue for a being you openly admit can't be percieved, you then try and drag those shattered remains of an arguement over magnificent claims about human life and the world. This is why I suggest to anyone who sincerely wants to put their effort into refuting a Christian to first, give up, and second attack the bible. No, don't set it on fire or throw it away, quote its passages, question the "context" that people try to throw at you, falsify its claims.

"Christianity" as I've said in the past has taken on so much more weight than mere belief in a book and the necessity of good and bad, for most educated people of the world. What used to be a shield for becoming frustrated or depressed about our situation has taken on the will to find any topic it can, lay an egg in it, and then have it reburst onto the scene like Alien. Easy example, non-believing Einstein who could've stood to re-word some things more carefully is quoted over and over and over by Dinesh in a mere charicature of the true meaning of his theories. Don't try to downplay Christianity because it is literally these things:

How people relate to their closest friends.
What people call love.
Where they find mental peace and understanding.
How they can find truth amidst their sometimes perfectly chaotic existances.
Moral
Purpose

The list goes on for however many interpretations that exist. Whether people want to say, no Christianity is X and god is Y, I think this is a lie when how they convey their faith comes across to me. For whatever reason people can't, or sincerely don't want, to disassociate the choice of viewing things that way, from the idea that they are divinely mandated.

Christianity aside, Dinesh goes for atheism. For the umpteeth time atheism is the LACK of belief, not something you can do an action in the name of, another thing Dinesh so ignorantly says you can do, over and over and over again. I've read Neitzshe and understand evolution and its not my "extreme Darwinism" and feindish lack of belief that would motivate publically unacceptable behavior. To keep hearing these things tied together is becoming more than annoying. No one has, nor ever will, wave the invisible flag of the Fairies after conquering a land that was mandated to them by the head invisible fairy.

I know that people are capable of keeping the bible in whatever context they want in their own minds. I keep hearing "read the bible for yourself" as the advice to my critisms. "keep things in context." My short answer to this is, read the other holy books, learn of the other religions, keep them in context, then tell me every single reason why you don't believe in them. When your list is compiled put "reasons why I don't believe you" and resubmit it to yourself. My frustration comes from people who try to disassociate themselves from the real world and tie all their problems into dogmatic belief. All I'm trying to say is that we're not so different, you and I, and if we could have a conversation where god remained in the realms outside of perception, you'd see why our same questions, confusions, and hardships are what really need to be focued on, and by throwing your arms in the air and proclaiming god, the only thing your "helping" is yourself.


Friday, August 29, 2008

[127] Some Sources

Friday, August 29, 2008 at 10:44pm

I didn't even realize how much I've watched....I'll keep adding to this list, I just didn't feel like finding everything in one night.

National Geographic: The Rivals of Jesus.
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/national-geographic-rivals-of-jesus.html

Critical analysis for case for a creator
http://www.movie-forumz.org/showthread.php?t=42608

Hovind/Shermer Debate
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eL-cORRZdng&eurl=http://www.movie-forumz.org/showthread.php?t=45258

The God who wasn't there
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2939815864103776582&hl=en

The Qur'an
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=6747824220828899563&hl=en

Many Faces of Benny Hinn
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=5582961561140514506&q=benny+hinn&ei=sBUISMbHCY-05ALb5fmrAQ

God, Darwin, and Design (Ken Miller)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=30_u9W6_UWA

The source for many more documentaries ranging from pretty good to complete crap.
http://www.movie-forumz.org/forumdisplay.php?f=47&order=desc

Debates

Dawkins on The Big Question
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ky_xRBy9M9U
Dawkins v Lennox
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRPSsKIOOoQ&feature=related

Barker v Fernandez
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1879356004848236265
Barker v Friel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cINIQqye0Hw
Barker,Carrier v Coret, Rajabali
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oocFLfoT0Q4

Shermer v Wells
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Pm9FC1S3Xs&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate

Barker v D'Souza
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1arsUJI00Ko&feature=related
Singer v D'Souza
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Phgb67NAaHA&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate
Dennett v D'Souza
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iw7J15TeDG4&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate?updated-max=2008-02-14T23%3A45%3A00-05%3A00&max-results=20
Hitchens v D'Souza
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2007/10/debate-between-christopher-hitchens-and_24.html
Hitchens v D'Souza 2
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/dsouza-vs-hitchens-freedom-fest-2008.html
Shermer v D'Souza
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2007/10/debate-between-michael-shermer-and.html

Scientific American v Mathis (Expelled)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiLYsj5B878&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate

Hitchens v Hitchens
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KmnVQLOd9Lg&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate
Hitchens v Boteach
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AynKncPYmv4&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate
Hitchens v Jackson
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFiy5dPwvY8&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate?updated-max=2008-02-14T23%3A45%3A00-05%3A00&max-results=20
Hitchens v McGrath
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2007/10/debate-between-christopher-hitchens-and.html

Myers v Simmons
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/02/pz-myers-vs-jeffery-simmons-evolution.html

Harris v Wolpe
http://www.jewishtvnetwork.com/?bcpid=533363107&bctid=1329234778
Harris v Hewitt
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8AR_yFSTIbg&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Christian

Link to a whole list of debates.
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Debate

Evolution

From RNA to Human: Evolution Symposium
http://www.rockefeller.edu/evolution/video.php?src=coyne
Meyers and Dawkins discussion
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XgqOKH6pwI&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Evolution
Digging for Humanities origins: Louise Leakey
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V-TGxJI4JwA&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Evolution
Ape Genius (This is so badass)
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/05/ape-genius-pbs-nova.html
J. Craig Venter: Joining 3.5 Billion Years of Microbial Invention
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/03/j-craig-venter-joining-35-billion-years.html
Dawkins: Break the Science Barrier
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/02/richard-dawkins-break-science-barrier.html
Human Life: Evolution to Self-Evolution
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/01/human-life-evolution-to-self-evolution.html
The Mark Steel Lectures Darwin
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pIvZvVJs0LI&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Evolution?updated-max=2008-02-15T20%3A13%3A00-05%3A00&max-results=
The Richard Dimbleby Lecture 2007: Dr. J Craig Venter A DNA Driven World
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2007/12/richard-dimbleby-lecture-2007-dna.html
For those stuck on the Dover Trial: NOVA ID on trial
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9R54LGX5_10&feature=related
The Genius of Charles Darwin (Parts 1,2,3)
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/genius-of-charles-darwin-episode-1-of-3.html

Link to a whole bunch of things semi-completely involving evolution
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Evolution

Other (I Feel) Important Links and Talks. I'll add much more later.

A.J. Jacobs: Year of living biblically
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5MkpzMAOZM&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Christian
Missionary Positions (Hilarious)
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/06/missionary-positions.html
Dispatches: In God's Name
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TeTfW8-dCNE&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Christian?updated-max=2008-06-16T10%3A42%3A00-04%3A00&max-results=
Bible Baby Bashers
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DP-s3AV9Kzs&eurl=http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/search/label/Christian?updated-max=2008-05-13T02%3A40%3A00-04%3A00&max-results=
A Question of Miracles (Corrupt preachers)
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/antony-thomas-question-of-miracles.html

The Bible

The History of the Devil
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/history-of-devil.html
How The Bible Explains Suffering
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/bart-ehrman-how-bible-explains.html
The Bible Unearthed
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05Oe1UAEATE
The Lost Gospels
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/bbc-lost-gospels.html
Banned From the Bible 1 and 2.
http://www.movie-forumz.org/showthread.php?t=9188

Genetics
http://atheistmedia.blogspot.com/2008/08/bbc-horizon-ghost-in-your-genes.html

Logical Fallacies
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q-Sq_AzbIJ4
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E9QBl7WJ_OM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gSrC0TQnqP8 (The Amazing Atheist)


Monday, May 5, 2008

[87] You Think I'd Learn...

Monday, May 5, 2008 at 7:28am

...to stop listening to Dinesh speak. I wish there was something this little doosh would get straight. There is no such things as a "christian morality." There are moral acts, and immoral acts. It kills me how many times he can repeat the same factually incorrect and ridiculous shit over and over again. "Atheist regimes have killed blah blah, secular society will doom us all, I'm going to attack the person I'm debating and never address an issue..." He tries to quote mine, completely take out of context historical claims and philosophies, and just outright lies about what it means to be an atheist or what his religion are responsible for. There is no such thing as "atheist principles." I'm writing this as I listen to him so I can quell my sudden anger at passing comments. There is a difference between a belief in a god and a belief in YOUR god. Here's the beautiful thing about arguing over this stuff. The judeo-christian god supposedly does and says things which we can no doubt test, that's where it fails. He is called omni-benevolent, all knowing, etc..Which obviously run into logical absurdities. Having given up trying to defend those absurdities, Dinesh just goes after speakers and presents "disaster scenario" propaganda.

Onto the issue of evil and suffering to which Peter Singer brings up. Dinesh accuses him of making an "atheist god" and then knocking that one down. A simple fact about a discussion about a god, you can't provide evidence for anything supernatural, invisible, "outside of space and time." I'm not telling you you can't simply because you can't, I'm stating that because its logically incoherent, its like saying there is something "more north" than the north pole or testifying at your murder trial. You can only judge whether that being "exists" or not by what is attributed to it. If I said anyone with brown hair got it from invisible fairies (bare with me), rounded up all the people with brown hair and said "O look how right I am," your going to think I'm retarded. This is precisely the way apologetics argue. They point to how things are, put a god tag on it, then shine that pious smirk. When Singer asks Dinesh to explain natural disasters that cause suffering, which have nothing to do with free will or a "fallen" race of people, its a valid question. When no one has been able to answer for the last 2000 years, it says something about your doctrine and your god, not "how we christians choose to interpret the problem" as Dinesh so dodgingly states. And of course because it doesn't seem answerable in our "earthly realm" power word "salvation" is kicked in. AHHH.

It's insufferable to listen to Dinesh in front of a sympathetic audience.

When an atheist like Bill Gates or Warren Buffet does something good, it can't just be them being good, no. According to Dinesh it would be because they are in a "christian culture" not because they are generous people. Another "tactic" that gets old. Wow, Dinesh said that objective good and evil do not exist in a Darwinian universe. I'm just going to say if that isn't the single sentence that tells you how ridiculous this prick is, then I'm at a loss. Dinesh just used the phrase "the atheism of the gaps." Got Mit Uns, God with us, on the belt buckles of the Nazi's. Hitler's personal journal. He was not an atheist. Was the holocaust denounced by the Catholic church? NO. I wish this one would go away. "Rabid atheists" on the list of things Dinesh has said.

I'm pretty sure I hate the debate format of these types of discussions. It lets so many little quips and assertions get lost in the entire picture. Dinesh is allowed to spew for 15 minutes straight listing off every nugget of junk he has in his arsenal. He doesn't read the entire BOOKS dedicated to a single sentence he claims to be true or false. He doesn't address any question ever. He jumps and flails, but does so emphatically that the ill informed just nod along. I'm sorry because if you've been reading along with me over the years I'm sure I sound redundant. I just feel like every time I hear the invalid arguments, every time I see passionate ignorance, I just have to say something back. I can't handle just holding it in.

Quick note an what it means to be an atheist. It's whatever the hell you want it to be. I'm sick of people trying to clump "atheist arguments" "atheist agendas" those dangerous "atheist societies" crap. There is no such thing as a collective of "lack of belief" in something. Let's take all the A-Santaists and travel the worlds schools informing the children of the truth....riiiiight. Let's take all the A-Unicornists and scorn Virgin Mobile commercials and artists. Atheists are not "without" god, they are not without morals. They don't believe in a god. There is no deficiency there. I wonder how many people have been liberated from the dreadful idea of eternal hell. What a burden to the atheists who can't swallow that from perfect love. The more I hear this kind of crap the more impossible, if you will, it becomes for me to believe in this stuff. I really don't understand why you would want to anymore. When I did believe in this stuff I just wondered how bored I would be in heaven.

The more Dinesh accuses people of being merely driven by their selfish genes and that you get nothing out of helping strangers, the more I want to beat the shit out of him. First off, its a ridiculous premise that has been explain by Dawkins an Dennett specifically. And second, its an outright lie to think people don't feel good when they can help others, nor do they forget what it looks like to deny the old lady your seat on the bus. I wanted to type COMMON SENSE and just put a period there, but apparently the more people speak they teach me there is no such thing as common sense. I'm fucking tired of hearing "christian value" as if nothing existed before the idea of Jesus. Dinesh says Springer isn't "following his atheism through." How does this make sense? Follow it through to where? What doctrine or infinite pinnacle is there to atheism? Give me a break.

I can't wait for death if only because I will go back to the peace I had before I was born. Dinesh just said we have no right to life. When asked if he was a "macro evolutionist" Dinest responds that he's not a biologist. "atheist assumptions/agenda" "metaphysical Darwinism" UUGH! Alright, I'm sick of this. Peace.

Buggah, I've spoken too soon. Dinesh says that it isn't possible for humans will be able to reach our wished for heights. It's not going to be us reaching higher, god has to condescend to the human level. I say that is a terrifically terrible idea to live by. Prove the christians who think this way wrong and be whatever type of person you strive for. Be a pinnacle of truth or hope and do it without thinking its impossible, because its not. You don't need an edict from god to love someone, you don't have to be unduly depressed by having goals and dreams that others disagree with. Screw that mantra. Be who want to with a finger flipped at the idea of heaven just to rub it in that your not in it for the eternal reward. Any "ultimate justice" is what you are going to provide for yourself if you choose to feel wronged. I truly feel sorry for you if you feel like you are nothing but a slave for god.
Updated about 6 months ago

Daniel Noah Robbin wroteat 1:20pm on May 5th, 2008
Well said, Nick. Well said.

On a side note, I can't believe people say 'Darwinism' like it's some type of belief. It doesn't relate to origination (Although his book's title says otherwise) but, rather, the process of evolution and how species are initiated through the development of others species.
Really gets on my nerves because 'Darwinism' is actually observable.
Report - Delete



Billy Bowman (Bloomington, IN) wroteat 6:13pm on May 5th, 2008
If he pisses you off so much... couldn't you like... not listen to him? Don't attend a debate, or watch the video online or however it is you listen to him... i think it might save you from having a heart attack at the age of 20.

Anyway, this particular line "Be who want to with a finger flipped at the idea of heaven just to rub it in that your not in it for the eternal reward." seemed to make me think an atheist who were to do something nice, might actually be... more... good ( that certainly sounds grammatically awkward..), then a christian who does something nice... interesting.



Saturday, December 29, 2007

[50] The Problem With Atheism by Sam Harris

(This is an edited transcript of a talk given at the Atheist Alliance conference in Washington D.C. on September 28th, 2007)
To begin, I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge just how strange it is that a meeting like this is even necessary. The year is 2007, and we have all taken time out of our busy lives, and many of us have traveled considerable distance, so that we can strategize about how best to live in a world in which most people believe in an imaginary God. America is now a nation of 300 million people, wielding more influence than any people in human history, and yet this influence is being steadily corrupted, and is surely waning, because 240 million of these people apparently believe that Jesus will return someday and orchestrate the end of the world with his magic powers.
Of course, we may well wonder whether as many people believe these things as say they do. I know that Christopher [Hitchens] and Richard [Dawkins] are rather optimistic that our opinion polls are out of register with what people actually believe in the privacy of their own minds. But there is no question that most of our neighbors reliably profess that they believe these things, and such professions themselves have had a disastrous affect on our political discourse, on our public policy, on the teaching of science, and on our reputation in the world. And even if only a third or a quarter of our neighbors believe what most profess, it seems to me that we still have a problem worth worrying about.
Now, it is not often that I find myself in a room full of people who are more or less guaranteed to agree with me on the subject of religion. In thinking about what I could say to you all tonight, it seemed to me that I have a choice between throwing red meat to the lions of atheism or moving the conversation into areas where we actually might not agree. I've decided, at some risk to your mood, to take the second approach and to say a few things that might prove controversial in this context.
Given the absence of evidence for God, and the stupidity and suffering that still thrives under the mantle of religion, declaring oneself an "atheist" would seem the only appropriate response. And it is the stance that many of us have proudly and publicly adopted. Tonight, I'd like to try to make the case, that our use of this label is a mistake—and a mistake of some consequence.
My concern with the use of the term "atheism" is both philosophical and strategic. I'm speaking from a somewhat unusual and perhaps paradoxical position because, while I am now one of the public voices of atheism, I never thought of myself as an atheist before being inducted to speak as one. I didn't even use the term in The End of Faith, which remains my most substantial criticism of religion. And, as I argued briefly in Letter to a Christian Nation, I think that "atheist" is a term that we do not need, in the same way that we don't need a word for someone who rejects astrology. We simply do not call people "non-astrologers." All we need are words like "reason" and "evidence" and "common sense" and "bullshit" to put astrologers in their place, and so it could be with religion.
If the comparison with astrology seems too facile, consider the problem of racism. Racism was about as intractable a social problem as we have ever had in this country. We are talking about deeply held convictions. I'm sure you have all seen the photos of lynchings in the first half of the 20th century—where seemingly whole towns in the South, thousands of men, women and children—bankers, lawyers, doctors, teachers, church elders, newspaper editors, policemen, even the occasional Senator and Congressman—turned out as though for a carnival to watch some young man or woman be tortured to death and then strung up on a tree or lamppost for all to see.
Seeing the pictures of these people in their Sunday best, having arranged themselves for a postcard photo under a dangling, and lacerated, and often partially cremated person, is one thing, but realize that these genteel people, who were otherwise quite normal, we must presume—though unfailing religious—often took souvenirs of the body home to show their friends—teeth, ears, fingers, knee caps, internal organs—and sometimes displayed them at their places of business.
Of course, I'm not saying that racism is no longer a problem in this country, but anyone who thinks that the problem is as bad as it ever was has simply forgotten, or has never learned, how bad, in fact, it was.
So, we can now ask, how have people of good will and common sense gone about combating racism? There was a civil rights movement, of course. The KKK was gradually battered to the fringes of society. There have been important and, I think, irrevocable changes in the way we talk about race—our major newspapers no longer publish flagrantly racist articles and editorials as they did less than a century ago—but, ask yourself, how many people have had to identify themselves as "non-racists" to participate in this process? Is there a "non-racist alliance" somewhere for me to join?
Attaching a label to something carries real liabilities, especially if the thing you are naming isn't really a thing at all. And atheism, I would argue, is not a thing. It is not a philosophy, just as "non-racism" is not one. Atheism is not a worldview—and yet most people imagine it to be one and attack it as such. We who do not believe in God are collaborating in this misunderstanding by consenting to be named and by even naming ourselves.
Another problem is that in accepting a label, particularly the label of "atheist," it seems to me that we are consenting to be viewed as a cranky sub-culture. We are consenting to be viewed as a marginal interest group that meets in hotel ballrooms. I'm not saying that meetings like this aren't important. I wouldn't be here if I didn't think it was important. But I am saying that as a matter of philosophy we are guilty of confusion, and as a matter of strategy, we have walked into a trap. It is a trap that has been, in many cases, deliberately set for us. And we have jumped into it with both feet.
While it is an honor to find myself continually assailed with Dan [Dennett], Richard [Dawkins], and Christopher [Hitchens] as though we were a single person with four heads, this whole notion of the "new atheists" or "militant atheists" has been used to keep our criticism of religion at arm's length, and has allowed people to dismiss our arguments without meeting the burden of actually answering them. And while our books have gotten a fair amount of notice, I think this whole conversation about the conflict between faith and reason, and religion and science, has been, and will continue to be, successfully marginalized under the banner of atheism.
So, let me make my somewhat seditious proposal explicit: We should not call ourselves "atheists." We should not call ourselves "secularists." We should not call ourselves "humanists," or "secular humanists," or "naturalists," or "skeptics," or "anti-theists," or "rationalists," or "freethinkers," or "brights." We should not call ourselves anything. We should go under the radar—for the rest of our lives. And while there, we should be decent, responsible people who destroy bad ideas wherever we find them.
Now, it just so happens that religion has more than its fair share of bad ideas. And it remains the only system of thought, where the process of maintaining bad ideas in perpetual immunity from criticism is considered a sacred act. This is the act of faith. And I remain convinced that religious faith is one of the most perverse misuses of intelligence we have ever devised. So we will, inevitably, continue to criticize religious thinking. But we should not define ourselves and name ourselves in opposition to such thinking.
So what does this all mean in practical terms, apart from Margaret Downey having to change her letterhead? Well, rather than declare ourselves "atheists" in opposition to all religion, I think we should do nothing more than advocate reason and intellectual honesty—and where this advocacy causes us to collide with religion, as it inevitably will, we should observe that the points of impact are always with specific religious beliefs—not with religion in general. There is no religion in general.
The problem is that the concept of atheism imposes upon us a false burden of remaining fixated on people's beliefs about God and remaining even-handed in our treatment of religion. But we shouldn't be fixated, and we shouldn't be even-handed. In fact, we should be quick to point out the differences among religions, for two reasons:
First, these differences make all religions look contingent, and therefore silly. Consider the unique features of Mormonism, which may have some relevance in the next Presidential election. Mormonism, it seems to me, is—objectively—just a little more idiotic than Christianity is. It has to be: because it is Christianity plus some very stupid ideas. For instance, the Mormons think Jesus is going to return to earth and administer his Thousand years of Peace, at least part of the time, from the state of Missouri. Why does this make Mormonism less likely to be true than Christianity? Because whatever probability you assign to Jesus' coming back, you have to assign a lesser probability to his coming back and keeping a summer home in Jackson County, Missouri. If Mitt Romney wants to be the next President of the United States, he should be made to feel the burden of our incredulity. We can make common cause with our Christian brothers and sisters on this point. Just what does the man believe? The world should know. And it is almost guaranteed to be embarrassing even to most people who believe in the biblical God.
The second reason to be attentive to the differences among the world's religions is that these differences are actually a matter of life and death. There are very few of us who lie awake at night worrying about the Amish. This is not an accident. While I have no doubt that the Amish are mistreating their children, by not educating them adequately, they are not likely to hijack aircraft and fly them into buildings. But consider how we, as atheists, tend to talk about Islam. Christians often complain that atheists, and the secular world generally, balance every criticism of Muslim extremism with a mention of Christian extremism. The usual approach is to say that they have their jihadists, and we have people who kill abortion doctors. Our Christian neighbors, even the craziest of them, are right to be outraged by this pretense of even-handedness, because the truth is that Islam is quite a bit scarier and more culpable for needless human misery, than Christianity has been for a very, very long time. And the world must wake up to this fact. Muslims themselves must wake up to this fact. And they can.
You might remember that Thomas Friedman recently wrote an op-ed from Iraq, reporting that some Sunni militias are now fighting jihadists alongside American troops. When Friedman asked one Sunni militant why he was doing this, he said that he had recently watched a member of al-Qaeda decapitate an 8-year-old girl. This persuaded him that the American Crusader forces were the lesser of two evils.
Okay, so even some Sunni militants can discern the boundary between ordinary crazy Islam, and the utterly crazy, once it is drawn in the spilled blood of little girls. This is a basis for hope, of sorts. But we have to be honest—unremittingly honest—about what is on the other side of that line. This is what we and the rest of the civilized, and the semi-civilized world, are up against: utter religious lunacy and barbarism in the name of Islam—with, I'm unhappy to say, some mainstream theology to back it up.
To be even-handed when talking about the problem of Islam is to misconstrue the problem. The refrain, "all religions have their extremists," is bullshit—and it is putting the West to sleep. All religions don't have these extremists. Some religions have never had these extremists. And in the Muslim world, support for extremism is not extreme in the sense of being rare. A recent poll showed that about a third of young British Muslims want to live under sharia law and believe that apostates should be killed for leaving the faith. These are British Muslims. Sixty-eight percent of British Muslims feel that their neighbors who insult Islam should be arrested and prosecuted, and seventy-eight percent think that the Danish cartoonists should be brought to justice. These people don't have a clue about what constitutes a civil society. Reports of this kind coming out of the Muslim communities living in the West should worry us, before anything else about religion worries us.
Atheism is too blunt an instrument to use at moments like this. It's as though we have a landscape of human ignorance and bewilderment—with peaks and valleys and local attractors—and the concept of atheism causes us to fixate one part of this landscape, the part related to theistic religion, and then just flattens it. Because to be consistent as atheists we must oppose, or seem to oppose, all faith claims equally. This is a waste of precious time and energy, and it squanders the trust of people who would otherwise agree with us on specific issues.
I'm not at all suggesting that we leave people's core religious beliefs, or faith itself, unscathed—I'm still the kind of person who writes articles with rather sweeping titles like "Science must destroy religion"—but it seems to me that we should never lose sight of useful and important distinctions.
Another problem with calling ourselves "atheists" is that every religious person thinks he has a knockdown argument against atheism. We've all heard these arguments, and we are going to keep hearing them as long as we insist upon calling ourselves "atheists. Arguments like: atheists can't prove that God doesn't exist; atheists are claiming to know there is no God, and this is the most arrogant claim of all. As Rick Warren put it, when he and I debated for Newsweek—a reasonable man like himself "doesn't have enough faith to be an atheist." The idea that the universe could arise without a creator is, on his account, the most extravagant faith claim of all.
Of course, as an argument for the truth of any specific religious doctrine, this is a travesty. And we all know what to do in this situation: We have Russell's teapot, and thousands of dead gods, and now a flying spaghetti monster, the nonexistence of which also cannot be proven, and yet belief in these things is acknowledged to be ridiculous by everyone. The problem is, we have to keep having this same argument, over and over again, and the argument is being generated to a significant degree, if not entirely, over our use of the term "atheism."
So too with the "greatest crimes of the 20th century" argument. How many times are we going to have to counter the charge that Stalin, Hitler, and Pol Pot represent the endgame of atheism? I've got news for you, this meme is not going away. I argued against it in The End of Faith, and it was immediately thrown back at me in reviews of the book as though I had never mentioned it. So I tackled it again in the afterword to the paperback edition of The End of Faith; but this had no effect whatsoever; so at the risk of boring everyone, I brought it up again in Letter to a Christian Nation; and Richard did the same in The God Delusion; and Christopher took a mighty swing at it in God is Not Great. I can assure you that this bogus argument will be with us for as long as people label themselves "atheists." And it really convinces religious people. It convinces moderates and liberals. It even convinces the occasional atheist.
Why should we fall into this trap? Why should we stand obediently in the space provided, in the space carved out by the conceptual scheme of theistic religion? It's as though, before the debate even begins, our opponents draw the chalk-outline of a dead man on the sidewalk, and we just walk up and lie down in it.
Instead of doing this, consider what would happen if we simply used words like "reason" and "evidence." What is the argument against reason? It's true that a few people will bite the bullet here and argue that reason is itself a problem, that the Enlightenment was a failed project, etc. But the truth is that there are very few people, even among religious fundamentalists, who will happily admit to being enemies of reason. In fact, fundamentalists tend to think they are champions of reason and that they have very good reasons for believing in God. Nobody wants to believe things on bad evidence. The desire to know what is actually going on in world is very difficult to argue with. In so far as we represent that desire, we become difficult to argue with. And this desire is not reducible to an interest group. It's not a club or an affiliation, and I think trying to make it one diminishes its power.
The last problem with atheism I'd like to talk about relates to the some of the experiences that lie at the core of many religious traditions, though perhaps not all, and which are testified to, with greater or lesser clarity in the world's "spiritual" and "mystical" literature.
Those of you who have read The End of Faith, know that I don't entirely line up with Dan, Richard, and Christopher in my treatment of these things. So I think I should take a little time to discuss this. While I always use terms like "spiritual" and "mystical" in scare quotes, and take some pains to denude them of metaphysics, the email I receive from my brothers and sisters in arms suggests that many of you find my interest in these topics problematic.
First, let me describe the general phenomenon I'm referring to. Here's what happens, in the generic case: a person, in whatever culture he finds himself, begins to notice that life is difficult. He observes that even in the best of times—no one close to him has died, he's healthy, there are no hostile armies massing in the distance, the fridge is stocked with beer, the weather is just so—even when things are as good as they can be, he notices that at the level of his moment to moment experience, at the level of his attention, he is perpetually on the move, seeking happiness and finding only temporary relief from his search.
We've all noticed this. We seek pleasant sights, and sounds, and tastes, and sensations, and attitudes. We satisfy our intellectual curiosities, and our desire for friendship and romance. We become connoisseurs of art and music and film—but our pleasures are, by their very nature, fleeting. And we can do nothing more than merely reiterate them as often as we are able.
If we enjoy some great professional success, our feelings of accomplishment remain vivid and intoxicating for about an hour, or maybe a day, but then people will begin to ask us "So, what are you going to do next? Don't you have anything else in the pipeline?" Steve Jobs releases the IPhone, and I'm sure it wasn't twenty minutes before someone asked, "when are you going to make this thing smaller?" Notice that very few people at this juncture, no matter what they've accomplished, say, "I'm done. I've met all my goals. Now I'm just going to stay here eat ice cream until I die in front of you."
Even when everything has gone as well as it can go, the search for happiness continues, the effort required to keep doubt and dissatisfaction and boredom at bay continues, moment to moment. If nothing else, the reality of death and the experience of losing loved ones punctures even the most gratifying and well-ordered life.
In this context, certain people have traditionally wondered whether a deeper form of well-being exists. Is there, in other words, a form of happiness that is not contingent upon our merely reiterating our pleasures and successes and avoiding our pains. Is there a form of happiness that is not dependent upon having one's favorite food always available to be placed on one's tongue or having all one's friends and loved ones within arm's reach, or having good books to read, or having something to look forward to on the weekend? Is it possible to be utterly happy before anything happens, before one's desires get gratified, in spite of life's inevitable difficulties, in the very midst of physical pain, old age, disease, and death?
This question, I think, lies at the periphery of everyone's consciousness. We are all, in some sense, living our answer to it—and many of us are living as though the answer is "no." No, there is nothing more profound that repeating one's pleasures and avoiding one's pains; there is nothing more profound that seeking satisfaction, both sensory and intellectual. Many of us seem think that all we can do is just keep our foot on the gas until we run out of road.
But certain people, for whatever reason, are led to suspect that there is more to human experience than this. In fact, many of them are led to suspect this by religion—by the claims of people like the Buddha or Jesus or some other celebrated religious figures. And such a person may begin to practice various disciplines of attention—often called "meditation" or "contemplation"—as a means of examining his moment to moment experience closely enough to see if a deeper basis of well-being is there to be found.
Such a person might even hole himself up in a cave, or in a monastery, for months or years at a time to facilitate this process. Why would somebody do this? Well, it amounts to a very simple experiment. Here's the logic of it: if there is a form of psychological well-being that isn't contingent upon merely repeating one's pleasures, then this happiness should be available even when all the obvious sources of pleasure and satisfaction have been removed. If it exists at all, this happiness should be available to a person who has renounced all her material possessions, and declined to marry her high school sweetheart, and gone off to a cave or to some other spot that would seem profoundly uncongenial to the satisfaction of ordinary desires and aspirations.
One clue as to how daunting most people would find such a project is the fact that solitary confinement—which is essentially what we are talking about—is considered a punishment even inside a prison. Even when cooped up with homicidal maniacs and rapists, most people still prefer the company of others to spending any significant amount of time alone in a box.
And yet, for thousands of years, contemplatives have claimed to find extraordinary depths of psychological well-being while spending vast stretches of time in total isolation. It seems to me that, as rational people, whether we call ourselves "atheists" or not, we have a choice to make in how we view this whole enterprise. Either the contemplative literature is a mere catalogue of religious delusion, deliberate fraud, and psychopathology, or people have been having interesting and even normative experiences under the name of "spirituality" and "mysticism" for millennia.
Now let me just assert, on the basis of my own study and experience, that there is no question in my mind that people have improved their emotional lives, and their self-understanding, and their ethical intuitions, and have even had important insights about the nature of subjectivity itself through a variety of traditional practices like meditation.
Leaving aside all the metaphysics and mythology and mumbo jumbo, what contemplatives and mystics over the millennia claim to have discovered is that there is an alternative to merely living at the mercy of the next neurotic thought that comes careening into consciousness. There is an alternative to being continuously spellbound by the conversation we are having with ourselves.
Most us think that if a person is walking down the street talking to himself—that is, not able to censor himself in front of other people—he's probably mentally ill. But if we talk to ourselves all day long silently—thinking, thinking, thinking, rehearsing prior conversations, thinking about what we said, what we didn't say, what we should have said, jabbering on to ourselves about what we hope is going to happen, what just happened, what almost happened, what should have happened, what may yet happen—but we just know enough to just keep this conversation private, this is perfectly normal. This is perfectly compatible with sanity. Well, this is not what the experience of millions of contemplatives suggests.
Of course, I am by no means denying the importance of thinking. There is no question that linguistic thought is indispensable for us. It is, in large part, what makes us human. It is the fabric of almost all culture and every social relationship. Needless to say, it is the basis of all science. And it is surely responsible for much rudimentary cognition—for integrating beliefs, planning, explicit learning, moral reasoning, and many other mental capacities. Even talking to oneself out loud may occasionally serve a useful function.
From the point of view of our contemplative traditions, however—to boil them all down to a cartoon version, that ignores the rather esoteric disputes among them—our habitual identification with discursive thought, our failure moment to moment to recognize thoughts as thoughts, is a primary source of human suffering. And when a person breaks this spell, an extraordinary kind of relief is available.
But the problem with a contemplative claim of this sort is that you can't borrow someone else's contemplative tools to test it. The problem is that to test such a claim—indeed, to even appreciate how distracted we tend to be in the first place, we have to build our own contemplative tools. Imagine where astronomy would be if everyone had to build his own telescope before he could even begin to see if astronomy was a legitimate enterprise. It wouldn't make the sky any less worthy of investigation, but it would make it immensely more difficult for us to establish astronomy as a science.
To judge the empirical claims of contemplatives, you have to build your own telescope. Judging their metaphysical claims is another matter: many of these can be dismissed as bad science or bad philosophy by merely thinking about them. But to judge whether certain experiences are possible—and if possible, desirable—we have to be able to use our attention in the requisite ways. We have to be able to break our identification with discursive thought, if only for a few moments. This can take a tremendous amount of work. And it is not work that our culture knows much about.
One problem with atheism as a category of thought, is that it seems more or less synonymous with not being interested in what someone like the Buddha or Jesus may have actually experienced. In fact, many atheists reject such experiences out of hand, as either impossible, or if possible, not worth wanting. Another common mistake is to imagine that such experiences are necessarily equivalent to states of mind with which many of us are already familiar—the feeling of scientific awe, or ordinary states of aesthetic appreciation, artistic inspiration, etc.
As someone who has made his own modest efforts in this area, let me assure you, that when a person goes into solitude and trains himself in meditation for 15 or 18 hours a day, for months or years at a time, in silence, doing nothing else—not talking, not reading, not writing—just making a sustained moment to moment effort to merely observe the contents of consciousness and to not get lost in thought, he experiences things that most scientists and artists are not likely to have experienced, unless they have made precisely the same efforts at introspection. And these experiences have a lot to say about the plasticity of the human mind and about the possibilities of human happiness.
So, apart from just commending these phenomena to your attention, I'd like to point out that, as atheists, our neglect of this area of human experience puts us at a rhetorical disadvantage. Because millions of people have had these experiences, and many millions more have had glimmers of them, and we, as atheists, ignore such phenomena, almost in principle, because of their religious associations—and yet these experiences often constitute the most important and transformative moments in a person's life. Not recognizing that such experiences are possible or important can make us appear less wise even than our craziest religious opponents.
My concern is that atheism can easily become the position of not being interested in certain possibilities in principle. I don't know if our universe is, as JBS Haldane said, "not only stranger than we suppose, but stranger than we can suppose." But I am sure that it is stranger than we, as "atheists," tend to represent while advocating atheism. As "atheists" we give others, and even ourselves, the sense that we are well on our way toward purging the universe of mystery. As advocates of reason, we know that mystery is going to be with us for a very long time. Indeed, there are good reasons to believe that mystery is ineradicable from our circumstance, because however much we know, it seems like there will always be brute facts that we cannot account for but which we must rely upon to explain everything else. This may be a problem for epistemology but it is not a problem for human life and for human solidarity. It does not rob our lives of meaning. And it is not a barrier to human happiness.
We are faced, however, with the challenge of communicating this view to others. We are faced with the monumental task of persuading a myth-infatuated world that love and curiosity are sufficient, and that we need not console or frighten ourselves or our children with Iron Age fairy tales. I don't think there is a more important intellectual struggle to win; it has to be fought from a hundred sides, all at once, and continuously; but it seems to me that there is no reason for us to fight in well-ordered ranks, like the red coats of Atheism.
Finally, I think it's useful to envision what victory will look like. Again, the analogy with racism seems instructive to me. What will victory against racism look like, should that happy day ever dawn? It certainly won't be a world in which a majority of people profess that they are "nonracist." Most likely, it will be a world in which the very concept of separate races has lost its meaning.
We will have won this war of ideas against religion when atheism is scarcely intelligible as a concept. We will simply find ourselves in a world in which people cease to praise one another for pretending to know things they do not know. This is certainly a future worth fighting for. It may be the only future compatible with our long-term survival as a species. But the only path between now and then, that I can see, is for us to be rigorously honest in the present. It seems to me that intellectual honesty is now, and will always be, deeper and more durable, and more easily spread, than "atheism."