Wednesday, November 15, 2023
[1078] Almost, Not Quite
Why? Why criticize anything ever? Why not "let people create" or "live and let live?" It sounds so simple and easy, right? No one is obligating me to engage with what they're putting out. Tastes differ. What's the point of investing any energy whatsoever into an opinion, particularly one that's less than supportive?
That's the framing from the uncritical. To them, all information can be treated equally. They act as though any piece of music, any article, movie, or any interaction with another person just exists in this neutral space with more or less equitable consequences and presumed decent enough reasons for their existence. It's why you can have dipshit day-time talk shows that have been having the same conversation since their inception. There's a gigantic herd of people ready to be info-taimed via the perpetual novelty offered through their ignorance.
There's only so much time. There's only so many stages, radio stations, movie studios, or remotely informed opinions it's worth incorporating into yours. If your time isn't precious, say, because you think you're going to live for eternity after you die, whether you spent 5 minutes or 50 years trying to inform yourself on something, it doesn't matter. It's hard to believe you have a real concept of "trying to inform yourself." I'd argue you're mostly killing time.
It's scarcity that breeds critical opinions. If there's truly moving, energetic talent out there, they only have so much in the tank. You want to promote them. You want to enable them and connect them with people who share not just some naive sensibility that broadly "celebrates artists," but can say, "Oh fuck, this is different, special, or plugged into the zeitgeist right now." People who are paying attention want to hear from others who are actually saying something. Finding voices in an endless scroll of noise is hard enough without entertaining bad arguments for bad art.
I criticized Ayaan Hirsi Ali under her article describing converting to Christianity. It was really poorly written. It was wholly devoid of any discussion regarding secular and scientific value systems, which, she's perfectly aware exist and has written about in the past, and just kind of discarded. She straw-manned the word "atheist" as if it's a value or belief system. She spoke to her failing mental health and fear as the things making the argument for her. It was really bad, especially for someone who's a noted figure on religion.
What was the pushback? I should allow her to feel what she feels. You know, because I have the power to stop her? Every time I hear this one it confuses the fuck out of me. The usual attempts to read my mind and question my character came in. Laugh emojis, personal stories about dead daughters who came back as undeniable signs. Just a ton of nonsense. Per usual, no one quotes me. No one asked me any questions. I'm not even sure most even read the article, and they definitely didn't read Michael Shermer's response, which I also shared.
In the non-critical mind, any perceived affront to someone's profession of "truth" is worthy of vitriol. It doesn't have to make sense. In fact, that's precisely the point. The more and more sense you try to make, the more you fuel the fire they'll use to burn you. You're not occupying the same universe of values, words, attention, or evidence.
Artistic works of all kinds, good or bad, impress upon us regardless of whether we want them to or not. How many advertising signs can you recognize quicker than people you went to school with for 4 to 15 years? How many jingles come to mind at their mere mention? We, creepily, applaud rhetoric and obfuscation from propagandists. Hitler is literally Hitler, and it's rare you hear him mentioned without props to his performances. Because that's what they are, efforts to compel your attention.
I've written a few songs. I play a few instruments. I've made a little documentary about the Merrillville Marching Band. I've written jokes. I've written 1,100 blog posts. I have as much of the creative spark as anyone, and yet I choose to share it with almost no one. You have to come to me and seek it out. You have to cling to the rotting corpse of facebook or have bookmarked blogger.
I put out things that I actually wish to say or I think are worthy of sparking more conversation or reflection. I'm not keen to spam our shared space with "demo" level noodling and experimenting if I know that's what I'd be doing. Let me write and record a song I'm proud of, you'll hear it. If someone comes in to criticize it who listens to exactly one band over and over again, I'll take them as seriously as I do people arguing religion with bronze age insights. I say or share jokes I think are funny and at least make myself laugh first or while I'm thinking about them. I share poems that burst out of me. If I ever got an opportunity to publish things I wrote, 95% of it would be left on the floor.
The same criticism applies to myself and people who wish to create "great" things. They want the work to be recognized, not hop between a series of flukes and incidentals. How many artists get popular with songs they don't even really like or thought they wouldn't include on an album? It's a lot. Listen to interviews about song-writing processes or thoughts as stars are on the rise. The cultural forces that popularize dumb or annoying one-hit-wonders are riding that ambivalent arm-chair capacity for evaluation or cynical spam. Is that what you feel about what you might create? It's so much more noise to be tossed into the ether?
The tools you develop in being critical you can apply across domains. You can be tough but fair to yourself instead of anxiously and despotically tearing down every effort you might make. You can borrow and allude to elements from patterns you notice verses plagiarize. You can work a sensibility into your bones that translates through nuances and between other critical sensibilities. You see this in music constantly in trading off jazz legends and guitar heroes.
I find myself begging for criticism sometimes. I don't exchange a lot of information for all I share. I have like 2 people left in my life who I can talk in depth or at length about some things with. We don't have a competent and critical culture. We have fandoms and feelings. We have tribes. We have overwhelming amounts of debt, sadness, health issues, and we're staring down the literal potential fascist takeover. It feels silly, one might think, to be critical of art or music at times like these. Irony forever wins the day and you might start arguing chicken vs egg.
If you dismiss, or are too exhausted, or "just don't care," or rush to call everything "fair" and declare what everyone's "rights" are as though you're not shitting on expressing them when they arrive in reactionary turn, you lose the whole game. A willingness to offer and engage sincere feedback bred from an earned perspective feels like it's wholly evaporated.
I have incredibly strong instincts about people and relationships that get proven too right way too often. I feel like I'm cheating and clearly must be ignorantly doing what others are so keen to do to me, but unfortunately I just keep seeing the same patterns and people willing to mindlessly let them play out. I'm deeply informed by having worked with, partied with, or attempted to engage in things "differently" or "better" with thousands of people over two decades. I actively listen to hundreds of bands and watch hundreds of shows. I've earned the right to say at least a little something about how someone or something is operating. I'm not stomping my foot and screaming my right to, I'm citing and reflecting on my experience.
Only when you do that do you afford yourself the opportunity to see how many gaps it contains. I can be incredibly right about someone's shitty romantic dynamic. It has nothing to do with every beat of their history and day to day that I'm not privy to. I can summarily dismiss cliche, boring, derivative bands and watch them soar never even knowing I exist. I can reduce the years I've spent learning about religion or human psychology to facebook pissing matches. Whatever amazing person that cunty moron might be when they're not talking at me I'll never know.
Take what gets into your head seriously. Respect yourself enough to utilize the evidence and recognize the patterns. They are there. From the fascist pattern to the shitty country music pattern, you don't have to listen or pretend it's tantamount to Bach. You don't have to stay silent as though your polluted landscape isn't worth coughing out of our collective lungs. All it takes is sincerely qualifying what you don't know, asking questions, and actually sharing what you believe is worth people hearing. We don't really have a prayer as individuals or as a society otherwise.
Sunday, June 12, 2022
[974] Bloody Needs
I may have lingered a little too long to capture what’s been on my mind, but here we’ll attempt to piece together what’s still floating.
I’ve found myself more capable of “disengaging.” I used to be pretty plugged
into the active gobbling up of information. I was ready with details, history,
citations, and rehearsed arguments for why “things” “should” look, sound, or
operate one way over another. My first bite of it was arguing about the nature
of healthy relationships, then I had mounds of religion versus science
exchanges. The primary reason I know anything about any philosopher was a manic
search for knock-out insights or phrasing for how to conduct life. I didn’t
have a specific or parsed understanding of what my problem was. I just knew I
needed “more.”
Conversational patterns seem to be the ones I’m most attuned to. I take in so
much from TV, books, or news that I can readily recognize when you’re being a
parrot verses thinking through something for yourself. A unique, albeit common,
perspective literally doesn’t sound like anyone else in an important way. It
has a kind of novelty that keeps you hooked when your perspective has that same
“more” hunger, and someone is speaking to what’s on your mind in a more
individuated and personal way.
A FOX viewer isn’t only “dumb” or “misinformed,” they’re inarticulate about the
mess of angry and afraid feelings, so they seek out the confirming narrative to
do the work for them. I was drawn to Jordan Peterson not because he was telling
me anything necessarily “new,” but he was articulating it in a personal way, imbuing
the story with his experience as a clinician and personal struggle trying to
understand human depravity. Elon Musk struck me in how he approached acquiring
knowledge and the emotional pain of being misunderstood at a fundamental level.
This is why I find criticism akin to, “We’ve heard this all before,” so severely
lacking in honesty or depth. If you can so quickly write-off a show because it’s
a “cop drama” or a person because they’re “famous for nothing,” you’re making a
similar error. This doesn’t mean you have to respect or enjoy those things, but
it does mean you’ve handicapped your capacity to understand what draws in other
people. Provided you’re still a person, you’re missing a way to tune into
yourself.
I think a lot about when I first learned why toddlers watch the same things
over and over. Surely the propensity of algorithmic media engagement preys upon
that. A movie has demonstrative and predictable patterns, and even still, you
can find different emotions or things you missed with each rewatch. This is
training. Just like when you remember something, even if .0001% of the memory
or retelling changes, it’s not the same each time. Each stroke of a FOX-induced
hate-boner is fractionally different and reinforcing. Each chant of a radical
mantra or prayer recitation the same thing.
The fact that we have so much to consume information-wise suggests that, whether
it be biological or some perfectly obscured mythically epistemological concept,
“more” is universal to the human experience. Whether you want more love, sex,
or food, it seems extremely rare, if truly in existence at all, that one is
just “okay” in or “at peace” in whatever manner they are. I read old blogs and
think about how desperately I felt the desire to get power, clean water, air
conditioning, a way to communicate from the middle of nowhere, my tools, time
to get things done, and the various piles of things I’ve acquired in service to
future builds. I couldn’t shut off my “more” valve if I wanted to.
What more do you want when you’re parroting someone else’s
script? What if it’s something you can’t get or can’t conceive of how to get?
Maybe it’s self-esteem and brainpower. You’re only born with so much brainpower,
and maybe you’re surrounded by people who give zero shits how they make you
feel. Maybe you can’t begin to understand how to carry a positive conception of
yourself independent of their imposing views.
What if you can’t even recognize that you’re running on someone else’s script? This
feels like a lot of the tension in generational differences or the thirsty
ideologues clinging to post-modern obscurity. A right-wing Christian
conservative antagonist should not be able to get so many doctors tripping over
their tongue about the question, “What is a woman?” One of the quickest ways
you know someone isn’t thinking rationally is circular reasoning. “A woman is
however she defines herself.” No. A woman isn’t that, any more than anything is
anything because you add more words that still reduce to, “The thing is the
thing because it’s the thing.”
An unwillingness to define a “thing,” is a pillar of not thinking. It’s why I
hate talking in “ists” and “isms.” You need a PhD in “feminism” to figure out
which sect and era’s position you might be speaking from. Do this messily, and
you might not even understand if you’re being an advocate or in opposition.
That fascist-speak can summarily dismiss “radical feminists” attests to this both,
in their irrational fallacious claim, and the in-built weakness of conceiving of
your position under the moniker. When you stick to asking questions like, “Do
you believe in equal pay” or “Do you hate men?” you figure out the individuated
position.
I don’t think a lot of us like to recognize how often we’re not thinking, or
how often we notice it in the people we’re feigning closeness towards. I’ve
experienced people driven together by mutually shared not-thinking narratives
regularly. It’s a behavior that’s rewarded and reinforced unironically. The group
can’t be a group if you’re popping your head up too often commenting on the unhealthy
nature or inadequate capacity of the group.
I challenge you to count how often you say something like, “Because that’s how
I feel.” You feel it “because,” or you feel because you feel. The insistence is
to respect feelings that, by regular demonstration are not reflected upon, not
given to understanding, and often have pretty dramatic and ongoing
consequences. If my mom lost her temper, my shit’s getting broken, I’m getting
beat, and we’re building in another layer of generational trauma to explore
with indefinite therapy. But I need to respect how she felt? My experience is
the same as someone in college challenged to think harder about what some “controversial”
speaker is “violently” discussing at a podium or on the street?
The landscape feels locked in this word-obscurity and language of feelings. And
the march from someone reasonable and healthy towards the high-stakes chaos of “cancellation”
and “de-platforming” I think played out like an abusive relationship. If he
only yelled at you in a scary way once in a year and a half, hit you just before
year 3, and all-along had made seemingly reasonable arguments at the time to chip
away at your autonomy, the drift was almost imperceptible.
If you tried to chronicle the shifts in our cultural
dialogue as it pertained to individual well-being, happiness, indulgence, capitalizing,
or decadent self-expression, and you’re 7-years old a few years after “greed is
good” becomes subconsciously instantiated in the cultural milieu, you don’t
have a prayer. “You need a college degree” or “middle-class house, wife, etc.”
as laws changed to exploit and prey upon you didn’t get noticed. You’re always
being supplied a narrative. You’re always being influenced by your biases and ingrained
practices. It’s incredibly hard to dig “you” out of all that.
I tend to write people off who I can’t recognize as their own “You.” You have a
problem you speak to time and again and refuse to change how you approach it,
perhaps. You have a “strong opinion” about something you’re absolutely
incapable of hearing conflicting or rounding evidence about. You engage in
things like questioning the person you’re talking to’s motivation for bringing
something up or asking at all. You find yourself incapable of drawing a conclusion
that isn’t the most damning interpretation of what’s been said or flat out
ignores or denies there’s anything else often literally in front of both
parties.
It gets old. It doesn’t seem to get old for most people as fast as it should.
Everyone seems to have some topic in which they’re as quick to circle up their
reasoning as the “irrational” or “asshole” over there. All you have to do is
poke something they’re insecure about. Getting old, fat, or ugly? Like a flash!
Body-positivity narratives wash over conversations about health and beauty
standards. Feeling oppressed? Here’s a hashtag drumbeat for shouting down critics.
You can lament the number of “phobics.” You can start a campaign to overthrow
the “violent” enemies who use their words in ways that did not respect your
feelings.
Meanwhile, big portions of reality appear, to me anyways, like they’re trending
towards some catastrophic reshuffling of who lives and dies and whether we
really continue down a path that nets more freedom, safety, and self-determination.
It’s hard to even recount the number of times I’ve been functionally shouted
down or isolated for talking, and I’m just an individual example of what we’ve
watched in the media on a global scale. I get incredibly frustrated when I
watch otherwise intelligent and thoughtful people invite cunts like Kellyanne Conway
to spin and spin and waste time like we don’t already know the fascist
playbook. We don’t need to reimagine “doublespeak” and invent the straw-man.
As much as I want “more” money, time, or freedom to fuck off and do whatever
strikes me in a given moment, I have a deep hunger for time around people who
have found themselves, or are making a genuine concerted effort to figure out
what parts are missing. I suspect I’ll be typing this same kind of story from an
increasingly regal circumstance I occupy in the future. I don’t really believe
that the culture I’m plugged into will provide me much beyond more stuff. I’m
incredibly thankful I can eek out the friendly individual here and there, but I
do, most often, feel the chill on connecting or speaking at all, let alone to
what’s really on my mind. I don’t find it valuable or worthy to share with
people who can only mindlessly consume and relish in the absurd antagonism of obscurity.
Monday, September 27, 2021
[927] Always Antagonize
I'm at the start of repeating another pattern.
