I want to talk about belonging.
As I try to understand what that means, I had times in my life that stuck out. It’s only a handful of periods in which I genuinely felt like I belonged. I want to see if they have anything in common besides however many stories I’ve written about how they went wrong.
My grandma’s house was a spot I belonged. The whole family would meet at my grandparents’ house for Sunday dinner and a movie. My grandma, in particular, would keep an endless supply of food coming, and was genuinely interested in spending time talking or playing cards. I remember once when I was maybe 13 or 14 I was having trouble sleeping, for months, at my house. I was sitting upright on the couch at my grandma’s, and remember nodding off, feeling, but not able to articulate then, an ease and sense of comfort that I was not finding in my chronically stressful and threatening home life.
I’ve felt like I belonged in two work environments, Showplace 12 as a teenager, and at DCS. At Showplace, I got to work early to hang out with friends, worked with friends, and then stayed out late after work with those friends. I knew and was good at my job. The management for most of the time felt like older siblings or surrogate parents who matched our maturity levels. I got looked out for when gossipy bitches tried to get me fired. The people who lasted could both do a good job and keep the fun and jokes alive all day.
At DCS any belonging stemming from knowing the intimate details of a very complicated job and getting a lot of positive feedback from professionals across realms. When the police defer to you, it’s hard not to think you’ve figured something out. When openly hostile school social workers eventually confide in you that they were thankful you were the one who got a particular child’s case, like, that’s your role, and you’re home. I got the chance to do a kind of ride-a-long with someone trying to understand an assessor’s day who I know they would have never gotten as much from anyone else. I got to train people who lit up after being mostly ignored or poorly informed by shittier coworkers for weeks. I could talk to judges at the “wrong” time and not get in trouble.
I also felt like I belonged with the college friend group and at the party house. There wasn’t knocking to enter each other’s houses. Mind you, that “group” is more of an imaginary distinction that spanned, to my mind, as many as 20 or more regulars, but nonetheless I felt the culture and vibe was something people were hungry for and hoped to belong to. I think a space of genuine connection and freedom was cultivated, in spite of how it was transformed and resented eventually.
Finally, I’ve felt at home, at least in humor and what I thought were shared expectations with my former best friend.
Throughout my life I’ve been a part of different sports teams and clubs. I’ve got a family. I’ve had longer-term girlfriends whose families I’ve met and spent time with. I’ve attempted to put together different hang-outs and make new friends. Always, I’m prepared for it to evaporate.
I’ve read a lot of books. I know there’s a cliche trauma-kid in there somewhere that can’t trust anything and had to grow up too fast. But I think the rift between me and other people goes deeper. Within the last couple years that might be described as still not diagnosed autism. Even still, I think, or at least I feel, like there’s an even bigger piece that’s still missing in this story.
Today, I have 3 main friends. 1 lives 3 hours away, who I’ve managed to spend more time with than the other 2 by miles. 1 lives 20 minutes away, is from Saudia Arabia, but has lived in the US for probably 20 years now. 1 lives 45 minutes away and I almost never see, but we text almost every day for brief spurts. All 3 of my friends appear to me to have something I don’t. They’re plugged into something “normal” or “familial” that I don’t feel.
That is to say, it’s the same kind of thing I witness in my ex-girlfriends and their relationships to their families. It’s the same thing I see come up from clients when they’re trying to articulate why they can’t adopt some behavioral change. It’s this kind of allegiance that people who all seem to suffer from something deep and peculiar all agree upon. And I have no fucking idea.
Let’s linger on the word “allegiance.” There’s this both from fairy tales and colloquial conversation that you pretty much ride-or-die with your lot. It doesn’t matter how bad they treat you, what they stand for, or what they’re likely going to do to you in the future
that’s your family. If they’re the reason you need anti-depressants, are in debt, or routinely shuffle and disrupt your self-care, no matter. You’re so overtly obligated that literally every violation forever is reduced to a write-off.
That’s only one side of it though. They also seem to be getting something wholly immersive and worthwhile. I might liken it to some kind of religious conviction that gets invigorated by each lash. With each donated strip of skin and drop of blood you’re one step closer to salvation. “You couldn’t possibly understand because you weren’t born into it,“ a furrow-browed and disgusted-with-me explainer might remark. It’s not for me and therefore shouldn’t be commented on or bastardized by my looseness or inability.
Movies about elves and orcs or super powers don’t make more money than anything ever has because the world is full of ”cool“ people. I don’t want to lose what I’m trying to articulate in some lazy idea of categories like ”nerd“ or ”outsider“ that plays the broken record of modernity citing their social anxiety or ”quirky“ introversion.
There’s something deep that people have that I do not.
My Saudi friend will get together with his other Arab friends and they’ll pray on his porch. My recovering alcoholic friend will spend as much time as she can get around her deeply alcoholic mom and sister. My 3-hours away friend will describe needing to stay closeted yet mostly enjoying her time with family who espouse many a fascist opinion and nearly re-traumatized her when she had to briefly move back in with them.
I think about the things people have cut me off over. It’s incredibly hard to square whatever this substance is that binds people together that might be 100 parts ”toxic“ for every dose of love or care. I will have people never talk to me again over rumors. They’ll cut me off when I’m ”too honest.“ I will get dragged into screaming matches so someone can build an excuse to run away, even as I’m literally offering food, money, time, and a white board writing things out to try and stay peaceful and connected.
Remember, I also have listened to hundreds of people’s descriptions of their histories and family lives. I’ve heard stories of years of physical and mental abuse turned routine. I’ve heard of theft, confinement, and substance abuse never being enough to tear some bond apart. I’ve had people report to me week after week for months or years the horrible things they’ve been called or accused of. They’ll tell me how they sacrificed savings or goals to ”help“ someone they care about. They’ll get genuinely aggressive and annoyed with me if I can’t phrase precisely my question about whether it’s wise to do so.
I know most people have an infinite capacity for self-destruction, including myself. So, no, I don’t think that’s what’s missing between us.
It has to be somewhere in the realm of positive emotion and that sense of belonging, no? I just watched His Girl Friday recently, and the whole joke of the movie is that the girl, no matter what else has transpired or been said, is his. They’ve got the magical bond that transcends literally everything. It’d be convenient to just write this off as an invention and mythology of the movies, iterated and evolved a million times, were I not witness to it from fucking everyone except myself.
I return to the battered-wife caricature so often because that’s what it feels closest to. I’ve also listened to a few podcasts recently just enamored by Christianity and the hold it has managed to have on society. It was novel to elevate the slave and espouse the idea that everyone has value. There’s not a more powerful tool in the universe than an indignant victim seeking self-righteous retribution. Oh! To be morally unencumbered! Is there anything more natural than a naked and afraid beast reacting after being provoked?
Most people are like my brother, and even my dad to a certain extent, when it comes to my batshit mom. I cut the bitch off at the first opportunity and haven't spoken to her in maybe 15 years? My brother invites her to his wedding instead of me. But, here’s the thing, of course he did and should have. He knows, like I know, that I’m not stuck to him or her or ”family“ like a normal person. I don’t belong. Weddings aren’t for ”people“ like me.
My 3-hour away friend’s dad remarked to her recently about our dynamic, ”whatever that is…“ He’s a little autism-y too, but also has clearly done the family-man, normal job, suburb life thing. His comment I feel articulates what my exes have felt instinctively.
What are they even doing? It’s extremely unlikely I’ll want to get married. My sense of being an adult in the world swings from doing drug studies, to food delivery, to ”real job“ with the State seemingly at random. I do this, and it’s been insisted, ”Nobody wants to be a blog,“ meaning the subject of mine. How did I trick them so thoroughly?
I’m like someone who has all of the pieces, but can’t make them fit. I’m not a weird-looking ”anxious“ I can’t, I can’t, I can’t type. I’m not unable or unwilling to modify my behavior to be ”more normal.“ Fuck, typing that line just made me feel a wave of incredible sadness lol. Especially as I’ve gotten older and heard so many people’s stories, I’m so much less inclined to hold any serious negative opinion or judgment towards someone. I’m a doubt and counter-factual machine at this point. Even my crazy cunt of a mother I can depersonalize and describe her objective tragic woes.
I feel like I’ve been longing for the sense of belonging that I had at my grandma’s. I feel like I know how I feel when I’m open and trying and enthusiastic about helping or sacrificing in service to someone I care about. I have been soundly rebuked by several exes for not only buying things spoken to as necessary to facilitate a goal but even just in offering money to help or fix something.
I feel like I’m literally trying and living the standard I wish for, but the options almost everyone chooses are some version of fatalistic calculation. I think most of my dad’s side of the family, for example, are jockeying for inheritance, my uncles already having stolen mine from my grandparent’s estate. Now them and my aunt want my great-aunt’s money. We play along at Thanksgiving or Christmas, but they don’t feel like family to me. Too much time in their presence, and I feel physically stressed. Do I want the money they stole? Sure, kinda, but not for what it’s probably gonna cost me.
”It’s a big club, and you ain’t in it.“
It’s never been my belief, in and of itself, in those times of belonging that has hurt me. It’s not that important to me if they were ”real“ or not because they felt real, and they feel different then the rest of my life. Incidentally, I’m not only accused, but it happens to be true, of not feeling particularly much beyond anger or spurts of happiness in general. I’m also loathe to give too much deference to feelings as a generalized rule. Who cares what I feel? That’s easy, fucking no one. I think I just care more about how those feelings inform or dignify the values I wish to live by. I want them free of the sticky muck that seems to inherently undermine their manifestation in shared reality.
That is, you can call your black eyes ”love“ all you want, I’m gonna think there’s something wrong with you. I’ll then be ushered into my shame corner for stating things so bluntly and condescended to because fear is the heart of love, idiot. It’s familiar and traditional and therefore worthy of identifying with.
My ex best friend couldn’t fight the temptation to prey on my sense of longing and hope to belong to something meaningful and robust. He got a whole house flipped off the back of it, and me complicit in a threat to my life. I believed the best about our dynamic right up until the moment I couldn’t. I voiced my displeasure along the way. I provided opportunities to make things right. But I no longer existed. That appears to be the end goal for nearly everyone I encounter in life. To act like what I saw, said, or felt wasn’t real. Whatever needs to get said or done to make explicit my wrongness or otherness is fair game. I couldn’t possibly be just like everyone else and
choosing to sound and act the way I do. Best to suffer my syndrome alone.